Comments are small addendums to each question or answer, intentionally limited in size and formatting.

learn more… | top users | synonyms (1)

-5
votes
2answers
266 views

Upvotes on Misleading Comment

I posted this answer here: http://math.stackexchange.com/a/1121698/205062 My answer was commented upon by someone who misunderstood it but that comment (the second comment) has attracted two upvotes. ...
4
votes
0answers
72 views

How to take an exchange of comments on math.stackexchange.com to a chat exchange?

I am baffled by the stack exchange user interface as regards chat. What do I do to take an exchange of comments on math.stackexchange.com to a chat exchange?
14
votes
2answers
205 views

Should the change in pre-filled text for custom close reasons be reversed?

Recently, I proceeded to vote to close a question. Because the primary reason to cast this vote was that it contained multiple questions, I considered using the free-form reason. In doing so, I ...
3
votes
1answer
36 views

Why doesn't [link description](URL) work for me in the comments?

I've posted a comment here: The $55$-th IMO, problem $1$ And it doesn't display the format [link description](link URL) properly. What is wrong?
1
vote
1answer
81 views

Answer deleted when flagged as “Should be Comment”

A new user, someone whom I introduced the site/community to, posted an answer to this question. It basically said: "I don't know about the overall problem, but for specific example you give, the ...
7
votes
1answer
429 views

Is it bad practice to comment on old questions with high views?

For instance, on this question I was going to ask about an English translation for one of the resources that was posted. I noticed that all the answers had no comment threads below them. My thinking ...
11
votes
1answer
266 views

Dealing with quality control comments

I contributed an answer to Is arrow notation for vectors "not mathematically mature"?, that, much to my surprise, has received lots of votes. However, someone whose profile says that they ...
0
votes
0answers
54 views

Questions which are answered through comments only [duplicate]

I have seen some questions (generally on the harder side of the spectrum) that seem to get answers which are only comments. For example in the form of a link to a paper, or someone just mentioning an ...
6
votes
2answers
666 views

Why is this not a comment, but an answer?

This answer here: http://math.stackexchange.com/a/1083253/1102 I flagged it as 'not an answer', as it ought to be a comment, but the flag was declined disputed. I believe there were a few delete ...
14
votes
1answer
335 views

Removal of a single “meta” comment on the main site

Some time ago there was a question that was tagged with elementary-set-theory. One user added set-theory in a suggested edit (that was accepted) and I removed it since I deemed that inappropriate. ...
-9
votes
2answers
240 views

Why is it that people down vote an answer without even bothering to comment what is the problem?

Why is it that people down vote an answer without even bothering to comment what is the problem? On many cases I find that people down vote my answer and I am not able to figure out who has downvoted ...
2
votes
1answer
116 views

Why do we have “See more comments”

I recently up-voted a savvy comment which implied that the OP should take a fresh look at his question. Then I noticed that there were more, currently hidden, comments. Only after I clicked to reveal ...
3
votes
0answers
54 views

How to select a comment as an answer. [duplicate]

There is my question, here till now in both the answers there is not anything what I needed and so none of them is selected by me. In comments under both the answers I'm getting something new and ...
3
votes
0answers
49 views

In activity log, no link to election comments

If you made or make a comment on the nomination page of the election it shows up in your activity log. However, unlike comments to questions, there is no link shown to the actual comment. Is this ...
8
votes
2answers
129 views

How should I respond to a moderator's comment on a deleted answer?

Arthur Fischer commented on one of my deleted answers asking why it was deleted. I do not know how he expects me to answer, since I seem unable to comment on it and I do not know of a way to PM other ...
16
votes
0answers
253 views

Why can't we upvote comments on nominations?

Why can't we upvote comments on nominations? Normally a user can vote on a comment to indicate that they agree with the sentiment in contains; this saves them from having to post a similar ...
10
votes
6answers
318 views

Is it inappropriate to post a “Thank you” as a comment?

Whenever an MSE user posts an answer to one of my questions, I always have a tendency to first post a comment thanking the user for his/her response, and then proceed to discuss the response, and ...
-9
votes
2answers
195 views

Do you think we should implement an incentive for leaving a comment when downvoting an answer?

I have noticed that a lot of times when an answer gets downvoted, there is rarely any feedback (unless the answerer asks for one or depends on the popularity of the question) for the downvote. With ...
31
votes
3answers
531 views

Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat.

I know that StackExchange encourages moving extended discussions to chat. I have also seen moderators actively moving extended discussions to chat. The question is, what's the point of this? ...
2
votes
0answers
176 views

Why are questions answered in the comments?

There seems to be an unusual trend going on. Even in the meta, I am seeing answers posted in the comments sections that could very fittingly have been in the answers section (meaning someone simply ...
4
votes
2answers
116 views

Comments missing from a thread that I didn't delete

I have noticed on a thread where I have had some comments that the comments on the OP and another persons answer are gone. I didn't delete them so why would the be deleted? One comment was about a ...
0
votes
1answer
75 views

New users should be informed to use @ when replying

It's getting silly how many times I notice people not using @ when replying to someone. This is very concerning since the one who replies never gets an answer. It should be written somewhere near the ...
11
votes
2answers
604 views

Closed questions fully answered into the comments

I don't think it is appropriate to answer closed questions into the comments as it happens here. Can (or should) we do something with such things?
4
votes
0answers
66 views

Comment rendered with MathJax overlapping text

I posted a comment to this thread, where I typed Can you add the same multiple of $2$ to $5$ and $17$ to make them both be either $1$ or $2$. The output is ...
-6
votes
1answer
123 views

Should upvoted comments gain reputation?

Why don't we give reputation for upvoting comments? I don't know what else to say. It seems like, just like the answer, they often give valuable insights that just don't accomplish the task from ...
5
votes
1answer
169 views

The “delete” option has disappeared for me in comments

Something odd has happened for me recently: The "delete" option on comments has, with sporadic exceptions, disappeared for me, as has the edit option. I'm also for the most part no longer seeing ...
-5
votes
1answer
255 views

“This doesn't answer my question” - hostility from asker

A couple of minutes ago I posted an answer to this question regarding the existence and calculation of $1/\pi$. I gave an algebraic answer appealing to the axioms of a field, while other askers used ...
-10
votes
2answers
123 views

could WDYT? acronym be listed as common acronym?

Very often I notice that homework questions are accompanied by a very low OP effort in trying to figure out by him/herself what the possible answer might be. When I see such questions (which usually ...
-5
votes
2answers
150 views

Allow an anonymous comment when voting

The problem: When up/downvoting a post (particularly for downvoting), it is often useful to leave a comment explaining why you are doing this so that the post can be improved, or so that the poster ...
19
votes
1answer
389 views

Is it okay to comment on others' answers for asking for explanation?

I often find myself waiting on the homepage of math.stackexchange.com, searching if there's a question I can answer. However, if I find a question (not posted by me), which is interesting for me, then ...
2
votes
0answers
47 views

Strange behaviour of MathJax in comments [duplicate]

It happened to me a couple of times to see MathJax code not properly rendered in a comment. All occurrences I remember of were caused by a Control Sequence being cut off too soon, as the ...
22
votes
1answer
676 views

Upvoting comments as equivalent of Facebook “like”: bad form?

Every now and then, I find comments which I like. Were I on facebook, I would put a like. Here on SX, "like" is not an available feature. The closest I can think of is upvoting. Sometimes I do, ...
32
votes
3answers
857 views

On mutual tactical serial upvotes and unconstructive comments

I notice that there is a group of users on this site who like to leave unconstructive comments on each other's posts. For example, A writes "Great answer, +1" on B's posts and B writes "Short and ...
27
votes
4answers
542 views

Is it bad form to answer a question using someone else's previous comment(s)?

I am sifting through some of the "Unanswered" and "No Answers" list, and — like so many before me — am finding that many of the questions have apparently been answered to the OP's satisfaction in ...
13
votes
1answer
358 views

Should we do something about old comments mentioning (homework) tag?

Not so long ago, the homework tag was blacklisted. However, we still have many comments on old questions containing some information about (homework) tag. This information is now obsolete. It is ...
6
votes
1answer
550 views

He has not enough reputation to comment and made a new question, how to proceed?

This question asks for an clarification of an answer of mine here. Do I post an answer to his new question, or do I post a comment in my answer and flag his new question? Remark: He did it, because ...
4
votes
1answer
125 views

How to mention someone in comments if his\her name doesn't appear after typing its first letters?

Suppose there is a question of a member $A$. I want to mention this member $A$(so it appears in the comment as "@A"). sometimes,when I type the first letters of name "$A$", The name appears in a ...
6
votes
2answers
139 views

How to proceed after question was answered in comments?

I asked a question and a user posted a comment of the form 'did you try ...'. This did indeed work and I consider the question answered. I wrote another comment on my question confirming that this ...
4
votes
1answer
129 views

How to go to the next line in comments?

When I write a comment, I don't know how to go to the next line because if I press Enter button It will submit the comment.
3
votes
1answer
89 views

Is it possible to insert an image in comments? if the answer is “yes”, then how?

Is it possible to insert an image in comments? if the answer is "yes", then how?
4
votes
0answers
58 views

Broken comment is un-editable and un-deletable [duplicate]

I added a comment to a question with broken MathJax tagging, and it is causing all comments to be formatted horribly and putting the "Edit" and delete buttons under the links on the right side of the ...
0
votes
0answers
73 views

Looking for template which says something like “the way of saying thank you is upvoting or accepting an answer”

I saw a question here on Meta with several templates but not the one I need. I remember seeing sometime ago a template that read more or less like: "the way of saying thank you here is upvoting or ...
2
votes
1answer
39 views

Comment notifications by edit?

When starting a comment with @Username, the referred user gets a notification message (red flag in his postbox). 1) If not starting a comment with @Username, and subsequently editing it with ...
7
votes
1answer
356 views

Question on users that don't accept answers.

I've seen on several occasion that it is not considered wrong to ask a user if he/she could please accept an answer. For instance it is discussed here. My question is slightly though significantly ...
17
votes
1answer
499 views

Comments of the form 'Please look at my question'

Some users (usually new ones) will see an answer to a question similar to one that they have recently asked, then leave a comment along the lines of 'Please look at my question . . .' Are such ...
1
vote
0answers
81 views

Questions that have been answered in comments [duplicate]

I have noticed an abundance of questions on the main site that have no answers, but have been answered in comments, often "accepted" with a comment such as "Thanks a lot!". Such questions bog down the ...
1
vote
0answers
76 views

can we remove the enter working as submit in comments? [duplicate]

Aan we change the working of the enter key when busy writing a comment At the moment it works like clicking the "add comment" button, and I rather would not like that functionality.
1
vote
1answer
119 views

automatic comment help

I was reading a question on aviation.stackexchange that had a number of comments. When I clicked on add/show comments to read the rest a small help window came up on the miniformatting in the comment ...
4
votes
1answer
132 views

Answers which should be comments

Today in the review queue I stumbled across an "answer" by a new user (1rep) which should be a comment. However, I was asked if it should be "deleted" or not. But it shouldn't be deleted - it should ...
2
votes
2answers
134 views

Should I flag comments, where long MathJax breaks page layout?

There were several posts mentioning that for various reason (mistake in the LaTeX-code, automatically inserted space) MathJax can break page layout: Formatting bug: long mathjax or code blocks break ...